Was Robert Neville the Murderer of Amy Robinson?

Arlington, Texas: The disappearance of 19-year-old Amy Robinson in 1998 , leaving law enforcement baffled and her family in anguish. Amy, a determined young woman living with Turner Syndrome, vanished on her way to work, triggering a search that would lead to a horrifying revelation.

Amy Robinson, described by her family as a trusting soul who saw only goodness in people, set out on her green bicycle for her job at a local grocery store on February 15, 1998. However, she never reached her workplace, prompting her family and the Arlington Police Department to launch an intensive search.

When a tipster claimed to have seen Amy talking to a white male in his 40s or 50s before he assisted her in loading her bicycle into the bed of his red pickup truck. The scenario echoed the notorious abduction and murder of 9-year-old Amber Hagerman in 1996, adding an ominous layer to Amy’s case.

Robert Neville

 Neville initially downplayed the nature of their relationship, he later claimed they were just friends through work.
Neville initially downplayed the nature of their relationship, he later claimed they were just friends through work.

Investigators encountered Robert Neville, a former colleague suspected of having a romantic involvement with Amy. While Neville initially downplayed the nature of their relationship, he later claimed they were just friends through work.

Days into the search, a breakthrough came when Michael Hall, a friend of Neville, confessed to his mother about his involvement in Amy’s disappearance. The revelation led to the issuance of arrest warrants for both Hall and Neville on charges of Amy Robinson’s murder.

Despite Neville’s initial cooperation with the police, the fugitive duo managed to elude authorities for 13 days. A crucial tip eventually led to their arrest at the Mexican border, where they were found armed and dangerous.


February 15, 1998Amy Robinson, a 19-year-old with Turner Syndrome, disappears on her way to work at a local grocery store.
February 15, 1998A tipster reports seeing Amy with a white male, echoing similarities to the Amber Hagerman case.
February 28, 1998A local car dealer reports lending Robert Neville an El Camino, revealing a crossbow in the vehicle.
March 3, 1998Neville and Hall are apprehended at the Mexican border, armed and dangerous, leading to their arrest.
March 3, 1998Neville and Hall confess to the murder of Amy Robinson, providing disturbing details to customs agents.
March 3, 1998Amy Robinson’s lifeless body is discovered in a grassy field near Hurst, Texas.
December 2, 1998Robert Neville’s capital murder trial begins, exposing his disturbing history and violent tendencies.
December 9, 1998Neville is found guilty of capital murder and sentenced to death by lethal injection.
2000Michael Hall’s capital murder trial commences, emphasizing the callousness of Amy’s murder.
Execution DatesNeville is executed on February 8, 2006, and Hall on February 15, 2011, marking 13 years since the murder.

Discovery of Amy’s Body

What followed was a chilling sequence of events that unfolded during the suspects’ interaction with customs agents. Neville and Hall, seemingly devoid of remorse, provided vivid details of how they lured Amy to a wooded area, ultimately leading to her death.

Upon their arrest, Arlington Police raced to a desolate area near Hurst, Texas, where they discovered Amy Robinson’s lifeless body in a grassy field. The postmortem examination revealed she had been shot to death, unraveling the horrifying truth behind her disappearance.

In recorded confessions, Neville callously admitted to killing Amy for the “adrenaline rush,” while Hall described the murder with a disturbing sense of detachment, referring to Amy as “a moving target” and laughing at the tragic events.

Capital Murder Trials

Neville and Hall faced separate trials, both eligible for the death penalty due to the nature of their crimes. Neville’s trial exposed a history of disturbing behavior, including early signs of violence such as setting fires and animal abuse.

Neville’s defense attempted to challenge the kidnapping enhancement to spare his life, but the jury, swayed by his own admissions, found him guilty of capital murder. He was subsequently sentenced to death by lethal injection and executed on February 8, 2006.

Hall’s trial, marked by his changed appearance and newfound religiosity, argued that he was under Neville’s influence. Despite this defense, the jury found Hall guilty of capital murder, and he too was sentenced to death. Michael Hall met his fate through lethal injection on February 15, 2011, precisely 13 years after the heinous murder of Amy Robinson.


For Amy’s family and the Arlington community, the trials brought a semblance of closure, knowing that Neville and Hall could no longer harm others. The case remains a haunting reminder of the vulnerability of innocence and the depths of depravity that led to Amy’s untimely demise.


Q: How did the police connect Robert Neville to Amy Robinson’s disappearance?

A: The police initially considered Neville as a person of interest due to his association with Amy at work. A tip later implicated Neville and his friend, Michael Hall, leading to their arrest and subsequent confessions.

Q: Were there any similarities between Amy Robinson’s case and the abduction of Amber Hagerman?

A: Yes, witnesses reported seeing a white male abducting both Amy Robinson and Amber Hagerman from their bicycles, loading them into red pickup trucks. The similarities raised concerns and added a grim layer to Amy’s case.

Q: What was the outcome of Robert Neville and Michael Hall’s trials?

A: Both Neville and Hall were found guilty of capital murder and sentenced to death. Neville was executed on February 8, 2006, and Hall met the same fate on February 15, 2011, exactly 13 years after Amy Robinson’s murder.

You May Also Like

More From Author

+ There are no comments

Add yours